A Part 35 compliant report is an expert report that meets rule 35.10 of the Civil Procedure Rules and paragraph 3 of Practice Direction 35. It is addressed to the court, gives the expert's qualifications, lists the material relied on, states the substance of all material instructions, makes clear which facts are within the expert's own knowledge, summarises any range of opinion, gives a summary of conclusions, and ends with a declaration of the expert's duty and a statement of truth in the prescribed form. Our CPR 35 guide sets out the rules one by one. This guide is the working version: what each requirement asks for in a medico-legal report, when the standard applies, how courts have treated reports that fall short, and what the expert and the instructing solicitor should each check before the report goes out.
The practical bottom line
- The contents list is fixed. Paragraphs 3.1 and 3.2 of Practice Direction 35 set what the report must contain, CPR 35.10 adds the substance of all instructions, and paragraph 3.3 prescribes the statement of truth.
- It applies once evidence is being prepared for proceedings. The test in CPR 35.2 is the purpose of the instruction. An expert retained only to advise sits outside it.
- Transparency runs through every item. What the expert was sent, what they were told, which facts they know at first hand and where each of the others came from.
- Non-compliance falls on the party. The court can exclude the evidence, make costs orders against those instructing the expert, or reduce the expert's fee (CJC Guidance para 91).
What does "Part 35 compliant" mean?
The phrase does not appear in the rules. It is the shorthand solicitors use in letters of instruction for a report that can be served and relied on under Part 35 without being sent back. Three sources define it:
- CPR 35.10. The report must comply with Practice Direction 35, end with a statement that the expert understands and has complied with their duty to the court, and state the substance of all material instructions, written or oral, on the basis of which it was written.
- Practice Direction 35, paragraph 3. The contents of the report (paras 3.1 and 3.2) and the form of the statement of truth (para 3.3).
- The Civil Justice Council's Guidance for the Instruction of Experts in Civil Claims 2014. Practice Direction 35 expects experts and those instructing them to have regard to it, and the report has to say the expert is aware of it.
Behind the contents list sits paragraph 2 of the practice direction, which sets the standard the contents are measured against. Expert evidence should be the independent product of the expert, uninfluenced by the pressures of litigation. The opinion should be objective and unbiased, and the expert should consider all material facts, including those that detract from it. A report can carry every required heading and still fall short of paragraph 2, and most of the cases later in this guide are about exactly that.
When does a report need to be Part 35 compliant?
Part 35 applies to a person "instructed to give or prepare expert evidence for the purpose of proceedings" (CPR 35.2). The test is the purpose of the instruction, whatever the expert's discipline. A consultant orthopaedic surgeon, a structural engineer, a forensic accountant and a care expert are all Part 35 experts once they are preparing evidence for a claim.
The CJC Guidance draws the line at advice. Advice from an expert before proceedings start, which the parties do not intend to rely on in litigation, is likely to be confidential, and the Guidance does not apply to it. The same goes for an expert instructed after proceedings start only to advise, for example to comment on a single joint expert's report. The Guidance calls that role an expert advisor (para 6). Everything applies again if the advisor is later instructed to prepare or give evidence (para 7).
In practice, personal injury and clinical negligence reports are usually commissioned to the Part 35 standard before a claim is issued, because a report the party intends to rely on will be served under Part 35 once proceedings begin. Writing to the standard from the first draft is the safer course. A breach of duty and causation report that has to be rebuilt after issue to add a statement of instructions or a dated list of materials costs time, and the gaps invite questions about what else changed.
Compliance does not replace permission. No party may call an expert or put in an expert's report without the court's permission (CPR 35.4(1)), and as the court said in Dana UK Axle, discussed below, that permission presupposes compliance with the rules.
The Part 35 compliance checklist
Each item is a requirement of CPR 35.10 or paragraph 3 of Practice Direction 35, with what it asks for in a medico-legal report and the way it is most often missed.
- Addressed to the court (PD35 para 3.1). The report is written for the judge. One that opens "Dear Sirs" and reads as a letter to the instructing solicitor starts on the wrong footing, however good the opinion inside it.
- The expert's qualifications (para 3.2(1)). The detail should match the nature and complexity of the case (CJC Guidance para 54). Academic and professional qualifications may be enough for a routine report. Where the issue calls for specialised expertise, include the training and experience that qualify the expert on that issue. In clinical negligence, where the standard of care is judged at the time of the treatment, it helps to show that the expert was practising in the relevant field at that time.
- Literature and other material relied on (para 3.2(2)). List all of it: the records by source, bundle and page range, imaging by study date and modality, witness statements by version and date, other experts' reports, and the published literature cited. The Guidance says the term instructions includes all the material the solicitors send, and that it should be listed, with dates, in the report or an appendix (para 55). An entry that reads "the medical records", with no dates or page ranges, cannot be checked by anyone.
- The substance of all material facts and instructions (para 3.2(3) and CPR 35.10(3)). Written or oral. The questions the expert was asked, any assumptions they were told to make, and any change of scope agreed on a call all belong here. The Guidance says the statement should not be incomplete or otherwise tend to mislead, and that leaving out "off-the-record" oral instructions is not permitted (para 55). The instructions are not privileged, but the court will only order their disclosure, or allow questioning on them, if there are reasonable grounds to think the statement of them is inaccurate or incomplete (CPR 35.10(4), PD35 para 5).
- Which facts are within the expert's own knowledge (para 3.2(4)). A medico-legal report usually draws facts from four places: the expert's own examination findings, the records, the claimant's account at interview, and the witness statements. Attribute each fact to its source. The Guidance asks experts to keep fact and opinion separate and to distinguish facts they know to be true from facts they assume (para 57). Where material facts are disputed, give an opinion on each version and leave the choice between them to the court, unless your expertise gives a reason to regard one version as improbable, which you then explain (para 58).
- Who carried out any examination, measurement, test or experiment (para 3.2(5)). Name the person, give their qualifications and say whether the work was done under the expert's supervision. In medical reports this catches psychometric tests administered by an assistant, nerve conduction studies, imaging reported by a radiologist whose report the expert relies on, and functional assessments. Where tests are scientific or technical, state the methodology too (CJC Guidance para 56).
- The range of opinion (para 3.2(6)). Where there is a range of opinion on a matter in the report, summarise it and give reasons for the expert's own view. If the range comes from published sources, explain them (CJC Guidance para 59). Where no source exists, the expert can set out the range they believe other experts would arrive at, making clear that it rests on their own judgement and explaining why (para 60). In clinical negligence the range of opinion sits close to the issue itself, because the Bolam test asks whether a responsible body of practitioners would have acted as the defendant did.
- A summary of conclusions (para 3.2(7)). Mandatory. The Guidance says it generally belongs at the end, after the reasoning, with a short summary at the start where the subject is complex enough that the judge would benefit from seeing the basis of the reasoning first (para 62).
- Any qualification to an opinion (para 3.2(8)). If the expert cannot give an opinion without qualification, the qualification goes in the report. Paragraph 2.4 of the practice direction adds that experts should say when a question falls outside their expertise and when they cannot reach a definite opinion, for example because the information is insufficient. Gaps in disclosure are the usual reason in medico-legal work, and our guide to missing medical records covers how to handle them.
- The declaration of duty and awareness (para 3.2(9) and CPR 35.10(2)). A statement that the expert understands their duty to the court and has complied with it, and is aware of the requirements of Part 35, the practice direction and the 2014 Guidance. CPR 35.10(2) puts the statement of duty at the end of the report. No wording is prescribed. A form that covers both the practice direction and paragraph 52 of the Guidance: "I understand that my duty is to help the court on matters within my expertise, and that this duty overrides any obligation to the person from whom I have received instructions or by whom I am paid. I have complied with that duty and will continue to comply with it. I am aware of the requirements of Part 35 of the Civil Procedure Rules, Practice Direction 35 and the Guidance for the Instruction of Experts in Civil Claims 2014, and I have complied with them."
- The statement of truth (PD35 para 3.3). In the prescribed form, including the contempt of court sentence. One trap is worth knowing about: paragraph 53 of the 2014 Guidance still prints the older form, which stops before the contempt sentence, so a template copied from the Guidance is out of date. Copy the wording from paragraph 3.3 of the practice direction. Our statement of truth guide gives the full text and explains what each sentence commits the expert to.
Every line of a compliant report answers a question the other side is entitled to ask: what were you sent, what were you told, and how do you know?
How do reports fail Part 35?
The judgments in which expert evidence was excluded or set aside turn on transparency and independence. Three of them show the pattern.
Material the other side never saw. In Dana UK Axle Ltd v Freudenberg FST GmbH [2021] EWHC 1413 (TCC), the defendant's three technical experts served reports that did not list the documents provided to them. Two of them had visited the defendant's factories without notice to the claimant, and the experts had been given technical material by the defendant long before the claimant's experts saw it. Permission to rely on the reports had been made conditional on revised reports giving full details of the materials provided and the source of the data behind each opinion. On an application made on day 7 of the trial, Joanna Smith J excluded the defendant's technical expert evidence. She held that the breaches of CPR 35, the practice direction and the 2014 Guidance would on their own have justified refusing permission (para 87), and that permission to rely on expert evidence "presupposes compliance in all material respects with the rules" (para 94).
A report that was not the expert's own work. In Van Oord UK Ltd v Allseas UK Ltd [2015] EWHC 3074 (TCC), Coulson J disregarded the claimants' quantum expert's evidence in full. The expert had prepared his report by looking only at his own side's witness statements, and had cut and pasted contested passages from them into it (para 82). He appended schedules that the claimants or their claims consultants had prepared without attributing them, and had not checked some of them (para 88). Assertions that read as his own views turned out to have come from discussions with the claimants' witnesses (para 89). The judge found that he was not independent (para 94). Each of those failures maps onto the checklist: the material relied on, who prepared what, and which facts were within the expert's own knowledge.
Leaving out what points the other way. In Muyepa v Ministry of Defence [2022] EWHC 2648 (KB), a personal injury claim for a non-freezing cold injury that was dismissed for fundamental dishonesty, Cotter J explained why the expert's statement of truth speaks of "true and complete" professional opinions: "An expert must not solely pick out pieces of evidence or entries in documents which provide support for the conclusion he/she has reached whilst not addressing material that points, or may point, the other way" (para 290). Where a contrary view is tenable, it belongs in the report, and he described leaving it to be raised by the other side's expert as a breach of the expert's duties to the court. He found that one of the claimant's pain experts "tended to stray from objectivity and into the role of an advocate for the Claimant" (para 278).
The sanctions sit on a scale. The CJC Guidance lists costs penalties against those instructing the expert, including wasted costs orders, disallowance or reduction of the expert's fee, and a ruling that the report is inadmissible (para 91). In more extreme cases the court can use its contempt powers, and an expert can face their professional regulator whether or not proceedings have started (paras 90 and 92). Our CPR 35 guide covers the costs and contempt cases, including Liverpool Victoria Insurance Co Ltd v Zafar.
What should the solicitor check before serving a report?
The expert signs the report and the instructing solicitor serves it. A short check at that point catches most of the problems above while they are still cheap to put right.
- Final versions. Before filing and serving, solicitors must check that any witness statements and other experts' reports the expert relied on are the final served versions (CJC Guidance para 61).
- Instructions against the file. The statement of instructions should match the letter of instruction, any supplementary instructions and any call that changed the scope.
- Materials against the file. The list of material relied on should match what was sent, by date. Anything sent later and missing from the list is a Part 35 question waiting to be asked.
- Questions answered. Each question in the instructions should have its own answer, in terms, where the reader can find it.
- The current statement of truth. Check that it carries the contempt of court sentence.
- Amendments. An expert can be invited to amend a report for accuracy, clarity, internal consistency, completeness and relevance, and should not be asked to change it in a way that distorts their true opinion (CJC Guidance para 65). Where the expert's view changes on a material matter after the report is produced, the change has to be communicated to all parties without delay (PD35 para 2.5).
Once the report is served, the other side has 28 days to put written questions about it. Our guide to Part 35 questions covers what they can ask and how to answer.
Is there a set template for a Part 35 report?
No. Practice Direction 35 prescribes the contents and the statement of truth and leaves the layout to the expert. The CJC Guidance points to model forms published by the Academy of Experts and the Expert Witness Institute, and to a template for medical reports created by the Ministry of Justice (para 51). Most medico-legal experts settle on a house template that carries the required sections in the same order every time. Our structure-first guide to writing an expert witness report sets out a workable order.
Does Part 35 apply outside civil claims?
Part 35 governs expert evidence in civil proceedings in England and Wales, in every discipline, so engineers', surveyors' and accountants' reports in civil claims are held to the same contents list as medical reports. Family proceedings have their own regime in Part 25 of the Family Procedure Rules and Practice Direction 25B, criminal proceedings in Part 19 of the Criminal Procedure Rules, and Scotland and Northern Ireland have separate rules. The principles overlap and the required contents and declarations differ, so a report written to Part 35 should be checked against the rules of the court it is going to.
How ALLDOQ fits
Most of the checklist is a record of the work: what arrived and when, what was read, and which page each fact came from. ALLDOQ keeps the records, the chronology and the report in one workspace. Each document carries the date it arrived, each chronology entry links to its source page, and the report opens from your own template with the Part 35 sections and declarations already in place, so the list of material relied on and the statement of instructions build up as you work. The opinion stays yours. To see it on a live instruction, book a walkthrough.
Sources
- Civil Procedure Rules, Part 35: Experts and Assessors (Ministry of Justice)
- Practice Direction 35: Experts and Assessors (Ministry of Justice)
- Civil Justice Council, Guidance for the Instruction of Experts in Civil Claims (2014)
- Dana UK Axle Ltd v Freudenberg FST GmbH [2021] EWHC 1413 (TCC)
- Van Oord UK Ltd v Allseas UK Ltd [2015] EWHC 3074 (TCC)
- Muyepa v Ministry of Defence [2022] EWHC 2648 (KB)